Chinese art historiography · Post-Interpretive Criticism
Research question
How can historical explanation reveal what a work makes possible, while remaining open to evidence that changes the account? This Museum of One programme takes up Lü Peng’s proposal to carry a discussion with Dorian Vale into practical research on specific works or historical cases. The inquiry asks how historical evidence, formal analysis, aesthetic experience and interpretive judgment can inform one another.
Programme record
- Research form: Art-historical case inquiry and methodological dialogue
- Current stage: In development
- Responsibility: Museum of One programme record by Dorian Vale. Lü Peng is the interlocutor and author of the published first response.
Current work
From evidence to judgment
Lü asks how a reader can follow the path from evidence to conclusion. The investigation distinguishes what a document or object establishes from historical judgment, scholarly inference and judgments of value. It brings archival corroboration and comparison among works into the same account as analysis of form, materials and visual structure.
From contact to artistic agency
Evidence that one artist encountered another’s work answers a different question from evidence of influence. The published discussion uses He Duoling and Andrew Wyeth, and Wang Guangyi and Andy Warhol, to open that distinction. A case can examine what was encountered, what was adopted, how it changed in the new work, and what that transformation meant in its circumstances. These pairs are examples from the exchange and give the inquiry starting points for comparison.
What could revise the account?
Lü proposes testing points of agreement and difference through works and cases. A study would track where close observation changes a contextual explanation, where documents clarify the work, and what new evidence could alter a judgment. The first public record is the two-part dialogue. Case selection and findings remain part of the developing research.
Outputs and developments
What Art Reveals, What History Explains
Status: Published dialogue · Two instalments on Lü Peng’s WeChat public account
Lü Peng and Dorian Vale. Read the first response and the reply with the original source links and archived PDFs.
Research context
Lü Peng (吕澎) is a Chinese art historian and curator whose writing and exhibition work helped establish how modern and contemporary Chinese art is studied. He served as chief curator of the 1992 Guangzhou First 1990s’ Biennial Art Fair (Oil Painting Section). Asia Art Archive preserves records from that exhibition and working materials for his early history of modern Chinese art, co-authored with Yi Dan.
In A History of Chinese Art in the 20th and 21st Century, Lü situates artistic forms and practices within China’s social and intellectual history. In the dialogue he brings that approach to questions about artistic agency, aesthetic experience, and what a historical account can establish from particular works.
Read Interpretation at Risk, the Post-Interpretive Criticism framework, and the Dialogues index.